Skip to main content

What about that Michael Moore Movie?

How dare they cast doubt on the sanctity of Renewable Energy?


Why am I feeling like this about that movie?

I have been asked by a LOT of people what I thought of Planet of the Humans?







Of course the movie has its story to tell and its own perspective that makes it interesting - it is a movie. The facts about renewable energy weren't off the mark. I don't know about the implied corporate handshake of our esteemed environmental leaders. I have only worked with Richard Heinberg, and have found him to be straight up.

What it is that is disturbing for people is that their perspective is being shifted.


You find out about climate change and climate destruction and you get over your shock and horror and denial, and then you want to bargain. You want to save the world. We will be good. We will use only good energy. We need wind and solar. We are good people. And so the narrative is formed and the story begins to become impervious to facts. 


You can find a talk that I gave on youtube years ago where I explained the limitations of renewables in terms of EROI. You can ask any energy engineer to explain utilisation factor, intermittency, conversion efficiency, energy density. 


Why this movie worked to dislodge the comfortable belief in the Holy Trinity of The Wind, The Solar and The Electric Car - I do not know. 


95 Thesis nailed to the church door? Doubting? Questioning? And being pretty logical and right in those doubts? Anyway, it's about time that the people who really do care about climate change move on from this bargaining position. 

They will feel angry that they were misled. They will feel guilty that they've been wasting time. 

And then they might start working on transition.

Comments

  1. Hi Susan !

    Glad you've done that blog. I've lost my time seeing this movie from start to finish due to the hype among my students...
    I think it can be at least seen as a very very first step into the problem for completely naive people...

    I return to thermodynamics without looking back.

    Raphaël

    ReplyDelete

Post a comment

Popular posts from this blog

Diagnosing Green Energy Mythosis

Diagnosis of a Green Techno-Miracle Mythosis (GT-MM)
An infectious thought virus that distracts from necessary change without causing any change.
Dr. Susan Krumdieck, 2014


At Risk Populations:
The most susceptible people will have preexisting anxiety about the subject of the GT-MM, but little resistance due to low technical knowledge levels

Symptoms:
The GT-MM thought virus can be identified by careful observation: ·presents with a green color ·presents with a nearly lifelike computer generated image ·presents as a solution to a problem, but the solution analysis is always missing ·presents as a "nearly ready" technology ·presents with call for further funding or government investment ·presents with images, words and symbols that are non-technical but seem technical to the susceptible host ·presents with anecdotal relevance, but no feasibility analysis ·presents with one or more technology components which are known by the target host - this is the "ring of truth" mechanism t…

Outrage and its role in Transition

Climate Emergency Outrage Outrage has been one of humanity’s key evolutionary strategies as we must have social structures in order to survive.
People who behave in anti-social ways must be called out and corrected in some way or they would pose a threat to the whole.When we perceive something being unfair or wrong and against our code of social conduct, then we, as a group (it is a group behaviour) call-out, shame, and express our outrage at the perpetrator. This shared outrage is the necessary vehicle for carrying out ostracisms and punishments that again, keep the group together. Think about it, we probably individually have too much empathy to be able to convict and sentence and imprison someone for 15 years for possession of a stolen TV. Could any of us individually carryout the socially mandated punishment to cut off the hand of a person who stole bread… but as an outraged group, yes we can carry out some pretty horrific punishments.
Researchers have found that when we get togethe…